Trending Fake Nails Out Of Paper : Then patiently and slooowly use the tip of the file in a tight circular motion, with minimal pressure, to if your fakes are acrylic, simply filing down the bit of glue till it's flush with the nail surface is an option. I just did these with a green tea arizona can and they turned out amazing! Fake Nails Out Of Paper - Emery paper would work best, as the metal would likely damage your nail file.